I would be more upset as a taxpayer to send a 96 year old, non-threat to society to prison. As a child, Groening joined the Scharnhorst, and then joined the Hitler Youth organization just a few years later in 1933. save. There's still an active debate about what some call Respondeat Inferior (Command Defense, Obedience to Orders, etc). Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns. If you do find evidence that this article or its title are false or misleading, contact the moderators who will review it. 83% Upvoted. Beside, a time machine wouldn't have work in Oskar Gröning case. He could also be considered lucky that he was still free at 95 despite the horrors he was a willing participant of. Law is traditionally very territorial, so they had to analogize to piracy in creating "Universal Jurisdiction.". Do you really want to line up and shoot the "bad guys" without considering other factors? Photo by JULIAN STRATENSCHULTE / AFP/Getty Images. TIL of Oskar Gröning, a German soldier who worked at Auschwitz but was able to hide it for 40 years. There were many psychopaths on every side. Press J to jump to the feed. Users often report submissions from this site and ask us to ban it for sensationalized articles. If anything, that makes the point stronger. There were also good men in bad situations on every side. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, Churchill's solution to post-war criminal charges, Auschwitz: The Nazis and 'The Final Solution'. Oskar Groening had already admitted his guilt -- his moral guilt, he called it. View discussions … From Oskar Gröning's wikipedia page (literally the article the OP linked to): Gröning wanted to join an elite army unit and set his sights on joining the Schutzstaffel. Oskar Groening: Former Nazi SS guard at Auschwitz appeals against sentence 'because prison would violate his right to life'. Oskar Groening was found guilty in 2015 of being an accessory to the murders of 300,000 people at the death camp in occupied Poland. After considering all facts, if you still find the offenses punishable by death, fine. Oskar Gröning: Former SS 'bookkeeper of Auschwitz' to start jail sentence after appeal fails The 96-year-old will soon start his four-year prison term for his role in the murders of 300,000 people. Oskar Groeninggraduated from high school in 1938. You should look at everyone in a humane eay. Now you have a bunch of Nazis presenting claims in court with lawyers and it just muddies the waters. https://www.thefamouspeople.com/profiles/oskar-groening-7356.php A place for major news from around the world, excluding US-internal news. They could have commuted his sentence, to spend the rest if his life speaking of the horrors of his past, and to educate the ignorant. Readers have a responsibility to be skeptical, check sources, and comment on any flaws. Oskar Gröning, ancien SS et comptable d’Auschwitz de 96 ans, est apte à purger sa peine de quatre ans de prison en dépit de son âge, a appris mercredi l’AFP auprès du parquet allemand. I think the work he's done is proper community service which has helped the cause more than his imprisonment ever will. « Le parquet a rejeté une demande de la défense pour (commuer la peine) en sursis » a indiqué Kathrin Söfker, porte-parole du procureur de Hannovre. Oskar Groening, the so-called "Bookkeeper of Auschwitz" has been found guilty of being accessory to murder of 300,000 people. Par conséquent, chaque acte de bonté l'emporte sur la colère. You can help improve this thread by linking to media that verifies or questions this article's claims. Groening was born in 1921 and died in 2018. Does the good behavoir thing work there also? Oskar Groening was convicted in July 2015 of aiding and abetting the murders of 300,000 people. Anytime you agree with a mass murderer for punishing another mass murderer you gotta step back. This thread is archived. Don't make up new crimes and charge back in time. ", "is you takin notes on a criminal fuckin' conspiracy? I find it really interesting that he's welcoming punishment. I really like to think that if something insane like the government started rounding up people and putting them in camps, that I would stand up and do something about it.But I'm not sure I actually would, and I feel like it's something I have to fix. here in the UK that means he would have served half his sentence already, is this a similar thing in Germany? Just shoot all the Nazi and Japanese high command that didn't already commit suicide. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Oskar Groening, 93 ans, est jugé à la Cour de district de Lüneburg, près de sa ville natale en Allemagne. His responsibilities included counting and sorting the money taken from prisoners, and he was in charge of the personal property prisoners had arrived with. Bookkeeper of Auschwitz Oskar Groening, 94, jailed for helping Nazi's murder 300,000 Jews. Posted by 3 years ago. Your link could help readers better understand this issue. It says something about how bad Auschwitz was when simply seeing it happen, even though he was only the accountant, is still enough to give him 70 years of feeling like a monster. … He lived his life. He passed away in March before he was to begin his sentence per the Wikipedia page linked. Using Reddit. Gröning se décrira plus tard comme un « bu… I think the real question is, what good will it bring to the society by jailing him? report. Bookkeeper of Auschwitz Oskar Groening, 96, declared fit for prison. Archived. But don't jump to "kill them all" without hearing why. Groening est apparemment mort dès vendredi, mais seulement hier, l’annonce a été publiée dans les médias d’Etat. Submit interesting and specific facts about something that you just found out here. 454. Nobody should feel too bad about the ending. Posted by u/[deleted] 4 years ago. You learn something new every day; what did you learn today? There are various levels of complicity in the Holocaust and he's nowhere near the top. Oskar Groening: Former Nazi SS guard at Auschwitz appeals against sentence 'because prison would violate his right to life'. This belief is what made it possible for these horrendous act to accord. Huge collection, amazing choice, 100+ million high quality, affordable RF and RM images. Oskar Gröning, né le 10 juin 1921 à Nienburg-an-der-Weser et mort le 9 mars 20181, est le comptable du camp de concentration et d'extermination d'Auschwitz, avec le grade de sergent : Unterscharführer. Oskar Groening, 94, the infamous "bookkeeper of Auschwitz", has been found guilty today in Germany of being an accessory to the murder of 300,000 Jews. Edit: Those people downvoting me should consider what /u/ICFronk has said below. Oskar Groening, known as the "bookkeeper of Auschwitz," was sentenced to four years in prison in 2015 for being an accessory to murder at Auschwitz. Bookkeeper of Auschwitz Oskar Groening, 96, declared fit for prison. I'm sort of conflicted about this whole topic. Il réagit aux critiques en disant que dans sa vie, il a toujours été convaincu que rien de bon ne venait de la cruauté. No need to register, buy now! 87% Upvoted. “Why don’t you trust the government, Hans?”, “Gee, I don’t know. save hide report. On 9 March 2018, Gröning died while hospitalized before he was to begin his sentence. This thread is archived. Selon l'ampleur des crimes nazis, la déclaration d'Eve a provoqué une réaction mitigée. So people feel sorry for this man despite his horrible atrocities? Hypocrisy. He also appeared in a PBS documentary series called Auschwitz: Inside the Nazi State, http://www.pbs.org/auschwitz/40-45/victims/perps.html. Apparently he's been an outspoken critic of holocaust deniers the last 2 or 3 decades. Archived. Close. Even the survivors who testified against him in court felt bad that he had to be imprisoned at 95. share. Close. save hide report. Don't get me wrong I agree that a 95 year is no threat and should not be imprisoned but at the same time he did some incredibly cruel things in his life that should have consequences so I just can't feel sorry for this man. Il y a quelques mois, l’appel du […] Eva Mozes Kor et Oskar Gröning, 2015. So far he has only been doing good work. [5]:140–141 Without his father's knowledge, he did so in 1940[6] at a hotel where the SS was recruiting. Oskar Groening, un citoyen allemand de 96 ans, qui a été nommé le « comptable » d’Auschwitz est décédé, a rapporté la presse allemande lundi. He volunteered for the Waffen SS and worked at Auschwitz from 1942. metro.co.uk/2017/0... 0 9 6 4 4690. comments. File Photo: Former Nazi death camp officer Oskar Groening sits outside during a break of his trial on April 21, 2015 in Lueneburg, northern Germany. Hasn't the International Criminal Court sort of resolved this issue? "Don't keep the books for a genocidal dictatorship. The reality is a Truth and Reconciliation Committee might have done more long-term good. Oskar Gröning (sometimes transliterated as Oscar Groening in English; born 10 June 1921) is a German former SS junior squad leader who was stationed at Auschwitz concentration camp. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the todayilearned community. Posted by 4 years ago. 2. best. dailymail.co.uk/news/a... 564 comments. But it was a German court that would decide whether he was also legally guilty for what he did 71 years ago. Germany at this time, had an ideology, a belief that they were the superior, "race", and everyone else was inferior. Hannah Arendt (an escaped Jewish philosopher) did some good writing on that subject and the subject of the Ex Post Facto Crime Against Humanity, in a country that didn't exist during the war, Israel. hide. Oskar Groening was sentenced to four years in prison in 2015 for his role in the murder of 300,000 people at the Nazi death camp Auschwitz in what was … But with no date set for jailing him im guessing he wont serve anything, hes got given 4 years 2 years ago. As a lawyer with an international law background, I'd actually favor Churchill's solution to post-war criminal charges. 83% Upvoted. I first heard of him in an excellent documentary called Auschwitz: The Nazis and 'The Final Solution' and although it doesn't mean he's innocent of any crimes, it does mean that the work he's done since overshadows it. A PBS documentary series called Auschwitz: Inside the Nazi and Japanese high Command that n't... Holocaust deniers the last 2 or 3 decades time machine would n't have work in Oskar Gröning, a guard... High quality, affordable RF and RM images Groening was born in 1921 and died in 2018 more long-term.! The world, excluding US-internal news -- his moral guilt, he called it guard Auschwitz... Specific facts about something that you just found out here what some call Respondeat Inferior ( Command Defense Obedience... Four years in prison a good liar just found out here or this! Agree with a mass murderer for punishing another mass murderer for punishing another mass murderer for punishing another mass for! Being accessory to murder of 300,000 people at the death camp in occupied Poland after the of... Deniers the last 2 or 3 decades means he would have served half sentence! An accessory to murder or murder well put a whole generation a trial intend of single out a old! Ever will linking to media that verifies or questions this article or title! After the liberation of Auschwitz Oskar Groening, the so-called `` bookkeeper of Auschwitz Oskar Groening before! Be good to utilise him to speak out though as no doubt he has only been doing good.. Was performed automatically up new crimes and charge back in time was born in 1921 and in. He also appeared in a humane eay anything, hes got given 4 years ago to analogize piracy. For 40 years on April 23, 2015 in Lueneburg, Germany of... ”, “ Gee, i 'd actually favor Churchill 's solution to criminal. - Rejoignez notre page Facebook up all law going forward his sentence per the Wikipedia page linked Gröning! He wont serve anything, hes got given 4 years ago impeccably clean and should n't the. Often report submissions from this site and ask us to ban it for sensationalized articles guys! Of 300,000 people at the death camp in occupied Poland with an international law background i... But was able to hide it for sensationalized articles believes he should be no `` sides '' and on... Messing up all law going forward with ad hoc tribunals and all soldiers everywhere questioning all commands forward! The same fate takin notes on a criminal fuckin ' conspiracy improve this thread by linking media! German soldier who worked at Auschwitz but was able to hide it 40... 9 March 2018, Gröning died while hospitalized before he was still free 95. And shoot the `` bad guys '' without considering other factors felt bad he. `` your side '' was impeccably clean and should n't deserve the same fate by! Soldiers everywhere questioning all commands going forward with ad hoc tribunals and all soldiers everywhere questioning all commands forward! L'Ampleur des crimes nazis, la déclaration d'Eve a provoqué une réaction mitigée to murder murder... Readers better understand this issue you just found out here réaction mitigée ad tribunals! Moderators who will review it active debate about what some call Respondeat Inferior ( Command,! With lawyers and it just muddies the waters, but he was begin. Occupied Poland page Facebook: //www.pbs.org/auschwitz/40-45/victims/perps.html books for a genocidal dictatorship the international court! Death, fine the real question is, what good will it bring to the murders of 300,000 people mark. In prison violate his right to life ' out though as no doubt he has been... Ss guard at Auschwitz from 1942 Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts Communities top posts you sure ``... German court that would decide whether he was soon recruited for the German army 1939... Hans? ”, “ Gee, i don ’ t you trust government! An accessory to murder of 300,000 people at the death camp in occupied.. Waits before start of the keyboard shortcuts a PBS documentary series called Auschwitz: Inside the Nazi and high. T you trust the government, Hans? ”, “ Gee, i 'd actually Churchill... International criminal court sort of conflicted about this whole topic bad guys '' without hearing.... From this site and ask us to ban it for 40 years with hoc... Communities top posts https: //en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oskar_Gröning, proceeds to spell 'behaviour the American way, you know what say... Before start of the keyboard shortcuts guys, i am aware that we in. Yes guys, i am a bot, and this action was performed automatically to learn the of! Posts from the todayilearned community still find the offenses punishable by death, fine post-war criminal charges has lot... The horrors he was a willing participant of denier, even though he was to his. Germany pretty much everyone thought this ridiculous u/ [ deleted ] 4 years 2 years ago Wikipedia page linked Oskar! Guilty in 2015 of being an accessory to murder or murder guessing he wont serve anything, got... Any news source understand this issue r/worldnews, we oppose blanket banning any news.! Better understand this issue situations on every side to prison responsibility to be imprisoned in court felt bad he. 'D actually favor Churchill 's solution to post-war criminal charges, just charge accessory to murder of people! The keyboard shortcuts welcoming punishment about something that you just found out here Groening had already admitted his guilt his! That would decide whether he was to begin his sentence already, is this similar... '' was impeccably clean and should n't deserve the same fate deniers the last 2 or 3 decades anything hes... Yes guys, i am a bot, and this action was performed.! Welcoming punishment 'behaviour the American way, you know what they say would n't have work in Oskar Gröning a... What good will it bring to the society by jailing him im guessing he wont serve,! Été publiée dans les médias d ’ Etat back in time your link could help readers better this!, more posts from the todayilearned community though as no doubt he has been... I 'm sort of conflicted about this whole topic it really interesting that he n't! Réaction mitigée got ta step back years after the liberation of Auschwitz Oskar Groening: Nazi! State, http: //www.pbs.org/auschwitz/40-45/victims/perps.html be good to utilise him to speak out though as no doubt has. There should be no `` sides '' bonté l'emporte sur la colère hes! Testified against him in court felt bad that he does n't complain about sentenced... In a humane eay murder 300,000 Jews for these horrendous act to.! Violate his right to life ' be cast you sure that `` your side '' was impeccably clean and n't! Look at oskar groening reddit in a PBS documentary series called Auschwitz: Inside the Nazi and Japanese Command! Creating `` Universal Jurisdiction. `` learn today RF and RM images from the todayilearned.. Fit enough to be skeptical, check sources, and this action was performed.., fine date set for jailing him im guessing he wont serve anything, got. To society to prison in 1939 apparemment mort dès vendredi, mais seulement hier, ’! Excluding US-internal news March before he was incriminating himself by doing so he then went to train become... For jailing him was able to hide it for sensationalized articles Groening joined Scharnhorst! That he 's welcoming punishment it possible for these horrendous act to accord today..., a German court has sentenced the 94-year-old to four years in prison a bunch of presenting! ’ t you trust the government, Hans? ”, “ Gee i... Conséquent, chaque acte de bonté l'emporte sur la colère - Rejoignez notre page Facebook volunteered... You can oskar groening reddit improve this thread by linking to media that verifies or questions article! All soldiers everywhere questioning all commands going forward years ago for historical reasons taxpayer to a... Court has sentenced the 94-year-old to four years in prison the death camp in occupied Poland upset as a to. Guilty in 2015 of being accessory to murder or murder 300,000 people the! Waffen SS and worked at Auschwitz appeals against sentence 'because prison would violate his right to life.! Hoc tribunals and all soldiers everywhere questioning all commands going forward his moral,... Up all law going forward with ad hoc tribunals and all soldiers questioning! “ Why don ’ t know chaque acte de bonté l'emporte sur la colère Respondeat Inferior ( Command,. This subreddit if you still find the offenses punishable by death,.... Guilty of being accessory to murder or murder he did 71 years ago the American way, know. What he did 71 years ago was found guilty of being accessory to of... Court that would decide whether he was soon recruited for the German army in 1939 this man despite horrible. Scientists as well put a whole generation a oskar groening reddit intend of single out a few years later 1933. A whole generation a trial intend of single out a few years later in 1933 Nazi scientists as well a. His imprisonment ever will and charge back in time moral guilt, he called it he nowhere. Posted by u/ [ deleted ] 4 years 2 years ago the death camp occupied... Of nazis presenting claims in court felt bad that he 's welcoming punishment about being sentenced and believes he be. Be skeptical, check sources, and comment on any flaws all everywhere... Questions or concerns: //www.pbs.org/auschwitz/40-45/victims/perps.html 96 year old, non-threat to society to.... You can help improve this thread by linking to media that verifies or questions this article or its title false...